AI Search Currently Drives Less Than 1% of Traffic To Most Sites, Google Is Still Dominant, and Watch The Long-term Risk of Ignoring Google Search

Posted on June 25, 2025
Source: The Internet Marketing Driver by Glenn Gabe. Read the original article

TL;DR Summary of How to Track AI Search Traffic in Google Analytics 4 and Why Ignoring Google Search is Risky

AI Search traffic currently represents less than 1% of most websites’ visits, while Google Search remains the dominant source of organic traffic. Setting up AI Search tracking in Google Analytics 4 (GA4) helps site owners accurately measure this emerging channel. Ignoring Google Search and overly focusing on AI Search risks quality issues that could be severely impacted by Google’s broad core updates affecting all search features.

Optimixed’s Overview: Understanding the Current Impact of AI Search and the Continuing Importance of Google Search

Current Landscape of AI Search Traffic

Despite frequent media hype about the rise of AI Search platforms like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and others, actual traffic from these sources remains minuscule—often under 0.5% to 1% of total site visits. Meanwhile, Google Search continues to drive the majority of organic traffic across diverse industries and website sizes. This disparity highlights the need for data-driven decisions rather than speculation.

How to Track AI Search in Google Analytics 4

  • Implement a custom channel group in GA4 specifically for AI Search traffic using tutorials such as Dana DiTomaso’s step-by-step guide.
  • Create custom reports to monitor traffic trends from individual AI Search tools alongside traditional search channels.
  • Use this data to compare AI Search traffic with Google Search and organic channels to understand their relative impact on your site.

Risks of Ignoring Google Search

Ignoring or deprioritizing Google Search in favor of AI Search can lead to significant SEO risks:

  • Quality issues may creep in if site owners overly focus on AI-generated content or unproven tactics targeting AI Search rankings.
  • Google’s broad core updates affect all search features, including AI Overviews (AIOs), AI Mode, the traditional 10-blue links, featured snippets, Discover, image and video search, and Google News.
  • Sites suffering from quality degradation could face widespread ranking drops across these features, with remediation often requiring months and multiple update cycles.

Balanced SEO Strategy is Crucial

Industry experts emphasize that a well-rounded SEO approach that already addresses content quality, technical SEO, and user experience will naturally encompass requirements for AI Search. Therefore, the rise of AI Search should not prompt radical strategy shifts but rather reinforce existing best practices.

Site owners are encouraged to set up AI Search tracking in GA4 immediately, analyze their own data, and maintain focus on Google Search as their primary traffic source while cautiously monitoring AI Search growth.