Mueller Says Serving a 200 Status Code During Downtime Can Get Error Pages Indexed
TLDR
Google's John Mueller says returning a 200 status code for down sites or error pages can make error messages appear in search results and cause duplicate pages to drop out of the index.
Optimixed Overview
Optimixed's original report on this story.
Google's John Mueller posted two reasons why serving a 200 status code to Googlebot during downtime is harmful. He said an error message on a down page can appear in Google Search results, and if identical error text sits across many pages, Google may de-duplicate them, causing those pages to drop out of the index. As first reported by SERoundtable, the guidance applies to sites returning error content with a success code.
How we got here: earlier coverage
- Nov 5Google Says It Can Temporarily Protect Important URLs Returning 4xx Errors From Deindexing
Google's Gary Illyes said Google Search can temporarily keep important URLs that return a 4xx status code in the index rather than removing them immediately.
- Oct 29Google Says Missing Pages Don't Hurt Rankings, but Recommends Custom 404 Pages
Google says 404 errors are not a ranking threat, but it recommends custom 404 pages because the experience visitors get after a missing page can affect a business.
- Oct 21Google advises sites to return 503 status codes instead of 404s when patching PHP to preserve indexation
Google recommends returning 503 status codes instead of 404s during server maintenance to prevent indexed pages from being permanently removed from search results.
- Sep 8Google says old low-value pages may continue to affect site recovery from ranking losses
Google's John Mueller indicates that old low-value programmatic pages can continue to harm a site's ability to recover rankings, even after removal or improvement.