Optimixed Search News

Shopping ad click-through rates are rising while impressions fall, possibly due to AI Overviews shifting which queries get ads

By Eric Mandell
62
AnalysisSpeculation

TLDR

Shopping ads show rising CTR paired with falling impressions, a pattern that may reflect AI Overviews redirecting lower-intent queries away from paid placements.

Context:3 closely related earlier stories since July

Optimixed Overview

Optimixed's original report on this story.

Search Engine Land reports on analysis by Mike Ryan of Smarter Ecommerce showing Shopping ad CTRs climbing—up roughly 20% in benchmark data and 17% year-over-year at Optmyzr—while impressions have fallen more sharply across thousands of campaigns. Ryan's hypothesis is that Google may be selectively serving AI Overviews on queries with lower predicted ad-click propensity while preserving Shopping placements for higher-intent searches, effectively shrinking ad inventory without proportionally reducing clicks. He cautions the data is not proof and notes his expectation that Google will eventually blend both experiences together as it develops AI-native ad formats.

How we got here: earlier coverage

On August 18, a nine-month analysis of more than 51,000 AI Overview events found that AI Overview prominence was volatile and that 22.4% of that traffic was misattributed to Direct in GA4. Later, on September 7, new data showed Google Shopping Ads gaining impressions and clicks while AI Overviews displaced organic results. Now, Shopping ad click-through rate is rising while impressions fall, a pattern that may reflect AI Overviews redirecting lower-intent queries away from paid placements.

Summary of earlier coverage

  1. Sep 7
    Google Shopping Ads See Reverse Crocodile Effect as AI Overviews Squeeze Organic

    New data shows Google Shopping Ads are gaining impressions and clicks as AI Overviews displace organic results.

  2. Aug 31
    Google Is Now Showing Shopping Carousel Ads Inline Within AI Mode

    Google is expanding ad placements in AI Mode by showing shopping carousel ads inline and at the bottom of results.

  3. Aug 18
    What 9 Months of AI Overview Tracking Reveals About Traffic, Citations, and GA4 Misattribution

    A nine-month analysis of 51,000+ AI Overview events reveals that 22.4% of that traffic is misattributed to Direct in GA4, AI Overview prominence is volatile, and Google favors structured, specific content.

  4. Jul 15
    Google AI Mode ads now appearing on nearly 30% of all search queries

    Google's AI Mode ads are now displayed on close to 30% of all search queries, reflecting the company's expanding push to integrate AI-generated content into search results.

Was this useful?
Share

More SEO News & Algorithm Updates stories

75
News

Google's Multiturn ads, which appear on responses to follow-up queries in AI Mode, appear to be live after Google announced them a couple of weeks earlier.

Paid Search & AdvertisingAI & Machine Learning in SEO
74
News

Microsoft is now showing both standard search ads and shopping ads at the top of Bing AI Mode results, which was formerly called Copilot Search.

Paid Search & AdvertisingAI & Machine Learning in SEOSEO News & Algorithm Updates
62
News

Google is testing AI-generated summaries that appear above the sponsored results group and beneath individual ad descriptions in search.

Paid Search & AdvertisingAI & Machine Learning in SEOSEO News & Algorithm Updates
58
News

Google Ads is testing a beta Asset Activity section in the advertiser console that uses Google AI to report on asset performance, diversity, competitors, and industry trends.

Paid Search & AdvertisingAI & Machine Learning in SEOTools & Platforms